Video: Battle of the Codecs: AVC vs. HEVC in 2016
If you have plans to deliver 4K video when the UHD standard goes mainstream, a migration to HEVC is almost certainly in your future. But should you make the jump now with the HD video you're delivering today? Should you convert your VOD archives? Avni Rambhia, Frost & Sullivan Industry Principal, Digital Media, tackles the pros and cons of taking the HEVC plunge and charts the future of both codecs in this excerpt from her presentation at Streaming Media East 2016.
Learn more about emerging codecs at Streaming Media West.
Read the complete transcript of the clip above:
Avni Rambhia: Every codec is fine-tuned for a certain resolution, and a certain application. If you're doing HD resolution or lower, there's no reason to switch away from AVC. The codecs are tested, the players work, the streams work, the DRM works, the analytics work, the advertising works. There is no reason to switch. There is even less reason to re-encode an entire humongous library that you may already have in existence. You can't do just-in-time transcoding very efficiently with HEVC.
The killer app for HEVC has always been 4K, and there's a new killer app in its arsenal: HDR.
As for 4K grows, and it is growing, I have I think the Indian Professional League, NASA, DirecTV, SwissCom, Rogers out in Canada with the National Hockey League, SkyVR with the Skycube boxes, Dish. With a list of people who are launching 4K, services are going to continue to grow.
HEVC is growing, but at a slow rate. HDR is also going to grow, but slowly; it's really hard to produce and create.
Finally, HEVC is slow. If you were to throw a CPU today at AVC and at HEVC, the gap between state-of-the-art AVC encoders and state-of-the-art HEVC encoders is not a 50% reduction, or a 100% reduction in bandwidth. It's a 15% reduction in bandwidth. AVC will hit an asymptote a lot faster, over time, by 2018 or 2020. HEVC's side of the bargain will get stronger because it will continue to improve in compression efficiency.
As of today, the gains that you're making in HEVC are more or less comparable to the gains you're making in AVC, so you have to keep that in mind as you're comparing the two as well. Finally, I know there's a lot of chatter about, "Well, if you can cut the bandwidth in half, your distribution costs go down by half; that's a big deal."
CDN pricing is dropping by half. The spread between the highest-priced contracts and the lowest-priced contracts gets wider and wider every year. If you can go through a wholesaler, or if you can negotiate a better contract, or if you can find a better CDN, it's a zero impact to the workflow method of reducing your bandwidth bill.
Related Articles
Bitmovin Solutions Architect Paul MacDougall assesses and compares current and emerging codecs based on several criteria in this clip from his presentation at Streaming Media East.
27 Aug 2018
Bitmovin Solutions Architect Paul MacDougall discusses current browser support and market share for emerging codecs such as HEVC and VP9 in this clip from his presentation at Streaming Media East.
20 Aug 2018
Bitmovin Solutions Architect Paul MacDougall outlines the playback challenges associated with emerging codecs in this clip from his presentation at Streaming Media East.
13 Aug 2018
Bitmovin Solutions Architect Paul MacDougall discusses the challenges to encoding and encoding decisions presented by emerging codecs in this clip from his presentation at Streaming Media East.
09 Aug 2018
Mozilla's Timothy Terriberry, Brightcove's David Sayed, and Twitch's Tarek Amara debate the future of streaming codecs at Streaming Media West 2017.
04 Dec 2017
Gogo's Prem Bangole discusses the cost/benefit analysis that led Gogo to migrate to HEVC/H.265 for in-flight live streaming, and how they implemented it with the airlines they serve.
07 Aug 2017
At its Worldwide Developer Conference this week, Apple announced it would support HEVC/H.265 in High Sierra and iOS 11 in a combination of hardware and software decoding, depending on the device. Here are the details of how Apple will implement it.
08 Jun 2017
HEVC Advance says it hopes to speed the adoption of HEVC decoders among the installed base of computers and devices by making some software downloads royalty free
22 Nov 2016
Netflix compared 5,000 clips from 500 titles in its library using the x264, x265, and libvpx codecs. x265's implementation of HEVC was the clear winner on quality and efficiency, but whether that matters in light of compatibility and licensing issues isn't so obvious.
02 Sep 2016
Speedy adoption of HEVC has been delayed by squabbles over licensing. Here, the developers of x265 propose steps to end the gridlock and move forward.
31 Aug 2016
Streaming Media EVP Dan Rayburn discusses the shifting emphasis in the CDN market from delivering bits to providing a complete ecosystem.
24 Aug 2016
Streaming Media EVP Dan Rayburn discusses why using multiple CDNs make sense for some content owners and not for others.
22 Aug 2016
Plex's Greg Edmiston, HBO's John Narus, and Machinima's James Glasscock discuss the challenges of controlling and standardizing the user/viewer experience across the diverse device landscape.
17 Aug 2016
Ooyala analyst Jim O'Neill and Machinima SVP James Glasscock discuss why content owners and broadcasters are recognizing the need to get on board with OTT in the face of cord-cutting.
15 Aug 2016
V-Factor Technologies' Jeremy Bennington explains how content providers can monitor live video delivery in real time and ensure consistent quality across different encoding profiles.
10 Aug 2016
Vimeo's Anjali Sud, StreamVPG's Scott Farb, and CME Group's Scott Szczurek discuss the latest marketing and branding content creation trends at Streaming Media East 2016.
08 Aug 2016
Vimeo VP of Platform Marketing Anjali Sud discusses successful (and not-so-successful) strategies for building branding campaigns with on-demand online video.
03 Aug 2016
Wowza's Ryan Jespersen outlines the workflow for streaming live 360° and virtual reality video from capture to ingest to stitching to delivery.
01 Aug 2016
MP & Silva's William Mao discusses the pros and cons of opting for an ad-based VOD model vs. building a subscription service.
27 Jul 2016
V-Factor Technologies' Jeremy Bennington explains how to test for and ensure consistent quality in VOD delivery within each encoding profile.
25 Jul 2016
Frost & Sullivan's Avni Rambhia discusses issues with latency, bandwidth, user experience, encoding, reach, and quality facing content creators as they make the leap into live VR.
20 Jul 2016
Streamroot's Erica Beavers makes the case for adaptive bitrate streaming and explains how to deliver the best possible user experience via ABR encoding.
18 Jul 2016
Panelists from NBC, Flix, and comScore discuss which OTT business models will and won't work going forward, and whether or not you need scale to be successful.
13 Jul 2016
Google's Serge Kassardjian, Whistle Sports' Brian Selander, and Recurly's Dan Burkhart discuss the challenges of differentiation in the OTT services market.
11 Jul 2016
RLJ Entertainment's Titus Bicknell describes how Acorn TV used an innovative strategy for adapting long-tail marketing to identify revenue streams in a broader assortment of niche content markets.
06 Jul 2016
Panelists from Streaming Media, Beamr, Brightcove, Verizon, and Yahoo! discuss the balance between encoding quality and bandwidth at Streaming Media East 2016.
29 Jun 2016
Twitter Manager of Content Strategy and Planning Nina Mishkin provides 3 strategic tips on how to leverage Twitter to get your videos seen, expand your reach, and grow your brand.
27 Jun 2016
Once you've decided on the bitrates that you want to deliver, it's time to determine the best resolution for each one, from 360p on up to 1080p. Streaming Learning Center's Jan Ozer shows you how.
24 Jun 2016
Streaming Learning Center's Jan Ozer explains how to choose data rates and resolutions for adaptive bitrate streaming to most effectively meet client expectations and end-user needs.
22 Jun 2016